Tag: Darwyn Cooke

Before Watchmen: Silk Spectre #4

Before the break I remember thinking that this Silk Spectre series was finally starting to live up to the expectations set by Darwyn Cooke’s other Before Watchmen book but all that momentum and all that good will was more than sucked away by the strange delay that has recently struck the range entire. The timing of this couldn’t be worse for Spectre which is not only the very first book back after the break, and thus the one tasked with reigniting interest, but it is also ending with this very issue. Doing this to a comic is like cutting the cinematic release of a film off just before the climax and then asking the audience to buy the DVD and find the end there amongst the deleted scenes. It’s stupid and a shame, but a strong enough story can survive it; is this such a story?
Read the rest of this entry »

Minutemen #4

Jesus Christ.

Darwyn Cooke’s artwork in this comic is so cute and almost cartoonish in its style that you can easily forget just how coarse and disturbed the content that he is depicting can get. For those wondering at home the answer to just how is that this issue is the darkest story that I have read or seen in a long, long time. More shocking than that though is the fact that it isn’t even slightly depressing because of this, instead I loved it for the bleakness of the tales tone, the barrenness of its world and the beauty with which both are rendered.

Read the rest of this entry »

Before Watchmen: Silk Spectre #3

Silk Spectre has given me the most conflicted reading experience of the Before Watchmen books thus far: on one side it has all the proper credentials, written as it is by Darwyn Cooke and drawn by the amazing Amanda Conner, but the two issues out so far have both failed completely in capturing me. Though Silk herself is the simplest and slightest of the characters given a series (until Moloch starts in November) the story that they tell about her is both the silliest and seemingly the least necessary of the lot – which is saying something. So even though Spectre is far from the worst in the series I was still disappointed when I saw that it was the title up this week, because the other titles are at least compelling failures that allow for creative criticisms whereas so far this one had just bored me. But no more…
Read the rest of this entry »

Before Watchmen: Minutemen #3

Alan Moore’s Watchmen has been given many honors over the years and heralded for initiating many changes to the comic medium, head amongst them is the fact that it popularized both the term ‘Graphic Novel’ and the act of buying these illustrated stories as books instead of issues. For me ten times out of eleven the trade is the superior way to read any story, regardless of its artistic intent, but I’ve slowly been coming around to the way of the floppy comic.

What DC have done with Before Watchmen though really showcases the flaws in the format: the writers they hired have mostly chosen to tell their stories slowly and over the course of the entire series, which has left many of these initial issues feeling a little lackluster and to top it off the prestige nature of the product and the constantly changing population of titles means that each individual book is now parceled out once every two months at most. This is a problem because any good serialized story will contain some complicated aspects, subtle character traits, hidden clues and dramatic cliffhangers; Cooke’s Minutemen has all of those, or at least I think it did but I can’t really remember now….

Read the rest of this entry »

Before Watchmen: Silk Spectre #2

Before Watchmen: Minutemen #2

Darwyn Cooke set this series of prequels off with a stunning book. While I only ended up liking it second best of the bunch i stand by what I said back in my review; that it was the perfect premiere issue in terms of style, content and quality. Not only was it a very good read but the issue also spent its time introducing to us (again, to most of us) the cast of characters who would go on to headline their own comics in later weeks. So it is that he was somewhat set-up to fail with this first of the second issues; for not only were expectations now high but the tricks tried there would not work a second time.

See A second issue brings with it new challenges: now we need the book to both stand on its own and step-out from the crowd, something easier said than done with what is essentially a ensemble piece. For seventeen pages I would say Cooke fails to meet these objectives, this issue feeling like an extension of the first, like more origin to already established characters and you almost lose interest but then he succeeds with the next few so well that not only do you forget all about Watchmen but you’ll barely remember reality or that you are reading at all.

Read the rest of this entry »

Before Watchmen: Silk Spectre #1

20120613-190754.jpg

1-0. So far so good, but so far still yet to go.

Zack Snyder’s Watchmen was the last time this special series was touched in a bad place and, in a lot of ways the last bit of news that prompted such primal controversy amongst comic fans; there weren’t many people pleased by the production taking place, to say the least. Though for a brief period during the casting the criticism dropped away, allowing hope to shine through for the first time; these weren’t big names but they were good ones and you know they kind of fit ( I daresay the same exact thing happened here when the writer/artist teams were announced for these books).

That newfound enthusiasm was, however, nowhere near enough to get people excited for the news that Malin Ackerman would be playing Silk Spectre, the stripperiffic spin that they put on her outfit certainly not helping matters. “She can’t act!” some said, “She’s just a pretty face” said others and much more – and much meaner things – besides; amongst these cries though came one that I instantly sided with and that call was this: “Well… It’s not like Silk Spectre was any different. She doesn’t so much have a story as she does sex, so what’s the big deal?”

Read the rest of this entry »

Before Watchmen: Minutemen #1

20120606-200308.jpg

And so the end is now no longer nigh but upon us, the horsemen ride and the bacon have hit the sky besides them; Before Watchmen is here, look upon it ye mighty and despair – as a certain Pharaoh’s poem once said – for if the hype is to be believed it brings with it the end of the industry and perhaps existence itself. While weeping may be one valid response to the sight of this issue on your local stores stands there is another much saner one, one that will despite all of the debate be the standard reaction: buying it. That is exactly what I did, then I read it and now I am here to write a little about what I thought of that experience; kind of like I would if this were just another new title, which is exactly how I am treating the series.

Watchmen was the first comic book that I ever read and so it does mean a lot to me, but so does Batman to a whole host of boys and DC release new Bruce books monthly without any uproar, it’s just accepted as what they do. Maybe if I were also someone who saw the cultural impact that comic had on the industry, or maybe if I were more of an obsessive personality (One of my greatest disappointments in life is that I am too tempered to ever go into a zionist rage over an art announcement) then I would think differently, but I don’t so here we are. As with those Batman books some of these Before Watchmen titles will be good while others are sure to be bad and so I aim in future to simply say of the issues in which camp they fall and why, with a bit of metaphorical deconstruction thrown in for fun; there won’t then be so much of an intro for each issue. So now to the issue itself. Read the rest of this entry »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 188 other followers